Anime season review

The Apothecary Diaries Season 1 Review

Scope
The first television season from 2023, without using story or ratings from season 2.
Year
2023
Author
CritiFilm Editorial Desk
Published

At a glance

A review of the first season's court mysteries, practical heroine, and carefully paced romance.

Editorial verdict

The Apothecary Diaries makes observation feel like an action scene, then lets its court mysteries reveal character as carefully as they reveal clues.

What works

Maomao's knowledge of medicine gives the mysteries a concrete logic, but her personality prevents the show from becoming a dry puzzle box. She is curious, skeptical, and often more interested in a poison than in the social performance around it.

The court setting supports both the mystery and the romance. Status changes what a character can say, while small gestures expose what official conversations hide. Jinshi's presence adds tension without reducing Maomao to a passive love interest.

The best cases use the setting as part of the clue. A change in food, clothing, access, or etiquette can carry as much weight as a dramatic confession, and Maomao's practical attention makes those details readable without making every answer obvious. The result is a story where character and investigation usually move together.

Where it is limited

The many names, ranks, and side characters can be difficult to track early on. Some cases resolve through information that was deliberately kept off-screen, so viewers who prefer to solve every clue alongside the protagonist may find the structure slightly selective.

The social hierarchy can also slow the emotional pace. Characters often have to speak indirectly, and the romance develops through implication rather than open declarations. That restraint suits the court setting, but viewers expecting a fast-moving romance or a clean case-of-the-week formula may need patience.

Who should watch

Watch it for character-led mysteries, palace politics, and a romance that develops through imbalance and restraint. It rewards attention more than background viewing.

It is especially suited to viewers who enjoy protagonists solving problems through observation, expertise, and skepticism instead of raw force. Keep track of names and roles as the season introduces them, and expect the story to value social detail as much as the final answer to a mystery.

Review details

Anime season English review

Media

Trailer

Video reviews (embedded, not hosted)

Can We Talk About the Apothecary Diaries in Excruciating Detail? (S1 EPS 1-3) - yumna

Watch on YouTube

The Secret Sauce That Makes Apothecary Diaries Work - Replay Value

Watch on YouTube

The Apothecary Diaries - Video Essay - Accented Cinema

Watch on YouTube

Metadata sources: source, source 2, source 3, source 4, source 5, source 6, source 7. We host no full streams.

Related reviews